New York Red Bulls Ny vs Columbus Crew Sc Clb Picks and Predictions November 3rd 2024

The Columbus Crew find themselves in a high-pressure situation as they prepare for a must-win match against the New York Red Bulls in the second game of their best-of-three first-round MLS playoff series. Facing elimination, Crew coach Wilfried Nancy’s key message to his team—and their fans—is simple but crucial: “stay calm.”

Crew’s Tactical Approach

Despite controlling 73 percent of the possession in the opening game, the Crew were unable to find the back of the net, suffering a 1-0 defeat at home. Felipe Carballo’s set-piece goal in the 25th minute, coupled with a standout performance from Red Bulls’ goalkeeper Carlos Coronel, who made eight crucial saves, proved to be the difference. Nancy emphasized that while the team executed most of their game plan effectively, they struggled in the finishing department.

“We played the game we wanted to, apart from the finishing and the goal we conceded,” Nancy explained. “We knew they would defend deep with a back five, and they executed that well. The message to the players is to stay calm, analyze the game carefully, and refine the details of our approach.”

The Crew’s game plan has often relied on fluid, possession-based football, with dynamic attacking runs and high pressing when off the ball. However, breaking down a disciplined Red Bulls defense that will likely deploy similar tactics on Sunday will require patience and clinical execution in front of goal.

Red Bulls’ Game Strategy

The Red Bulls, the No. 7 seed, came into the first match as underdogs but executed their strategy perfectly, disrupting Columbus’s rhythm with high-intensity pressing before dropping into a compact defensive block. Coach Sandro Schwarz emphasized the need for continuity in their high-energy approach while remaining adaptable.

“It’s important to focus on the next game,” Schwarz said. “We need a different solution but the same intensity. Columbus is a very good team, so we must stay sharp and ready for another battle.”

The Red Bulls’ ability to absorb pressure and capitalize on set pieces or transitional opportunities makes them a dangerous opponent, especially when playing at home in Harrison, N.J. Their defensive structure and Coronel’s heroics will again be pivotal.

Key Players and Wild Cards

One of the biggest potential game-changers for the Crew is the expected return of Diego Rossi. The forward, who contributed 12 goals and 11 assists in the regular season, missed the opening game due to a back injury but is set to feature on Sunday. Rossi’s speed and attacking intelligence could help unlock the Red Bulls’ defense.

“He’s a fast player, so he offers us a threat in behind,” said Crew midfielder Max Arfsten. “He runs a lot and is dynamic. It’ll be nice to have him back, and he should provide us with another dimension offensively.”

On the Red Bulls’ side, the physicality and defensive organization that worked so well in the first game will be key. Players like Carlos Coronel and Felipe Carballo will look to replicate their impact performances, while the rest of the squad will aim to maintain the high intensity and strategic discipline that gave them the edge in Columbus.

What to Watch For

Columbus’ Finishing

The Crew’s ability to capitalize on their possession and create quality scoring chances will be under scrutiny. Their high-powered attack must find ways to test Coronel early and often. Key players like Cucho Hernández and Lucas Zelarayán need to step up and take advantage of every opportunity.

Red Bulls’ Defensive Setup

Expect the Red Bulls to employ a similar strategy, using their defensive block and counter-pressing to frustrate the Crew. How they handle the return of Rossi and Columbus’s adjustments will be crucial. Maintaining discipline in defense and minimizing mistakes will be top priorities.

The Midfield Battle

The central areas will be fiercely contested, with both teams looking to gain control and dictate the tempo. Columbus will need to move the ball quickly to break lines, while the Red Bulls will focus on disrupting that flow. Players like Darlington Nagbe will be key in transitioning from defense to attack for the Crew.

Discover Winning Strategies! Click here for the latest Soccer Picks and elevate your game predictions.

Match Outlook

With their season on the line, the Crew must bring both intensity and composure. Wilfried Nancy’s call for calmness is a reminder that panic can lead to costly mistakes, especially in a hostile away environment. Meanwhile, the Red Bulls will be looking to feed off the energy of their home crowd and use their tactical discipline to close out the series.

Should the Crew manage to win and force a decisive third match, they’ll be grateful for the return leg in Columbus on November 10. Until then, Sunday’s showdown promises to be a high-stakes, strategic battle where every moment and every touch will matter.