New York Mets Picks

If you’re looking to bet on the Mets, don’t miss our top picks:

At ScoresandStats.com, our handicappers are always betting on the MLB. Within the last 30 days, our top 5 handicappers have raked in a few thousand dollars from their wagers. 

As you can see, one of our highest rated handicappers, Brandon Lee, has a 73.33% win rate, having only lost 4 of his last 15 wagers. All of his picks for the MLB are available with the Started Plus package, which is just $9 per month. You could use his picks to win just as much as he does!

New York Mets History

The New York Mets were born in 1962, a time when New York City was longing for a National League team following the departure of the Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Giants. The Mets joined Major League Baseball as an expansion team, and though their early years were challenging, they became beloved for their underdog spirit. In their inaugural season, the team finished with a record of 40-120, the worst in MLB history, but the passion of their fanbase was undeterred.

By 1969, the Mets had transformed from lovable losers into champions, capturing the hearts of fans with their “Miracle Mets” run to the World Series title. Behind the superb pitching of Tom Seaver and Jerry Koosman, they stunned the baseball world by defeating the heavily favored Baltimore Orioles in five games. This triumph remains one of the greatest underdog stories in sports history and cemented the Mets’ place in New York sports lore.

Throughout their history, the Mets have been a team of highs and lows. In 1986, they captured their second World Series title with a memorable victory over the Boston Red Sox, a series defined by the infamous error by Bill Buckner in Game 6. The Mets have seen other playoff runs since then, including a trip to the World Series in 2000 and again in 2015. Despite their often rollercoaster-like performance, the Mets remain one of baseball’s most iconic teams with a dedicated fanbase.

New York Mets Timeline

• 1962: The New York Mets are founded as an expansion team, replacing the departed Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Giants in the National League.
• 1964: The Mets move into Shea Stadium, their new home located in Flushing, Queens.
• 1969: The “Miracle Mets” win their first World Series, defeating the heavily favored Baltimore Orioles in five games.
• 1973: The Mets win the National League pennant but lose in a seven-game World Series to the Oakland Athletics.
• 1983: The Mets acquire future Hall of Famer Keith Hernandez, a key addition to their eventual championship team.
• 1986: The Mets win their second World Series in one of the most memorable series in baseball history, defeating the Boston Red Sox in seven games, highlighted by Bill Buckner’s error in Game 6.
• 1988: The Mets return to the playoffs but lose in the NLCS to the Los Angeles Dodgers, who go on to win the World Series.
• 2000: The Mets reach the World Series again, losing to the crosstown New York Yankees in the “Subway Series” in five games.
• 2006: The Mets win the NL East and make it to the NLCS, but fall in Game 7 to the St. Louis Cardinals after Carlos Beltrán strikes out looking to end the game.
• 2015: The Mets win the National League pennant and advance to the World Series, where they lose to the Kansas City Royals in five games.
• 2022: The Mets win 101 games, one of the best regular-season records in franchise history, but they are eliminated in the Wild Card round by the San Diego Padres.

New York Mets MLB Record

The Mets had an OK 2024 season, going 89-73. They finished 3rd in the NL East, but did improve significantly from 2023, where they were 75-87, 4th in NL East. 

The Mets postseason has been much better for them, moving up the ranks of the Playoffs. It remains to be seen if they can beat out the Dodgers later in the series. 

New York Mets Stats

For the 2024 season, the New York Mets had a mix of strong individual performances and disappointing team results. Here’s a breakdown:

Pitching Stats

Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander were the headliners of the Mets’ rotation, but injuries derailed their seasons. Scherzer finished with a 3.74 ERA and Verlander, while still effective with a 3.39 ERA, missed several starts. The bullpen, led by closer Edwin Díaz, who saved 35 games with a sub-2.00 ERA, was a bright spot for the team. Overall, the Mets ranked 11th in team ERA, but their inconsistency made it tough for bettors relying on their pitching to hold leads.

Batting Stats

Pete Alonso once again led the offense with 44 home runs and 110 RBIs, maintaining his status as a premier power hitter in the league. Francisco Lindor contributed significantly as well, batting .271 with 28 home runs and 98 RBIs. As a team, the Mets struggled with consistency, ranking 14th in the MLB in runs scored. This mid-tier offense made them a volatile team for bettors in over/under markets.

New York Mets Roster for 2025

Looking ahead to 2025, the Mets will likely see some changes, particularly in the pitching staff, as Verlander and Scherzer may be nearing the end of their time in New York. Key players like Pete Alonso, Francisco Lindor, and Brandon Nimmo are expected to remain at the core of the team. 

Young players like Brett Baty and Francisco Álvarez will continue to develop and could become major contributors. Expect the Mets to pursue starting pitching in free agency, given their reliance on aging veterans in 2024. A strong bullpen led by Edwin Díaz should return, making them a team to watch, particularly in games with tight spreads.

New York Mets Injury Report

In 2024, injuries to Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander played a significant role in the Mets’ underwhelming performance. Their absence for key stretches of the season led to inconsistency in both starting pitching and overall team success, which frustrated bettors expecting the Mets to contend for a division title.

To learn more about which Mets players are injured, check out or comprehensive injury report page:

New York Mets 2025 Betting Outlook and Trends

If the Mets keep up their postseason record, they’re looking to situate themselves as a rising underdog in the NL. Our handicappers think there are a few trends that might emerge in the 2025 season:

• Fade Aging Pitching: With Verlander and Scherzer nearing the end of their careers, their consistency will be a major question mark. Bettors should be cautious backing the Mets on the moneyline when these aging aces are on the mound, particularly against younger, more dynamic lineups.
• Rising Stars: Francisco Álvarez and Brett Baty are developing into cornerstone players. Expect their improved performances to affect player prop markets, particularly in home run and hits markets, making them valuable targets in specific matchups.
• Bullpen Reliability: The Mets’ bullpen, anchored by Edwin Díaz, will remain a strength. Bettors should consider taking the under in games where the Mets hold a late lead, as their bullpen has a high success rate in preserving narrow leads.

Betting Trends from 2024

If you’ve been following the Mets this year, you’ve likely noticed their poor starting pitches and inability to clutch key moments. However, bettors who were armed with this information were able to make some money. 

Here are some popular betting trends that emerged during the Mets’ 2024 season:

• Inconsistent Starting Pitching: Injuries to Scherzer and Verlander caused volatility in Mets’ moneyline bets. Bettors who faded the Mets during their uncertain pitching matchups often saw success.
• Pete Alonso Home Run Props: Alonso’s power remained one of the Mets’ most reliable betting angles. Bettors who consistently took Alonso to hit a home run in favorable matchups (particularly at home) found value throughout the season.
• Unders in Close Games: With the Mets’ bullpen performing well, games with low-scoring opponents often saw the under hit, especially in matchups against divisional foes like the Miami Marlins and Washington Nationals.

Key Players for Betting on the New York Mets

Don’t be afraid to supplement your spreads, totals, and moneyline wagers with player props. The Mets have some star players that can be quite profitable to wager on. Some key players to keep an eye on include:

• Pete Alonso
• Francisco Lindor
• Max Scherzer
• Edwin Diaz
• Francisco Alvarez

Pete Alonso

Pete Alonso remains one of the premier power hitters in baseball, consistently ranking among the league leaders in home runs. His ability to turn any mistake into a long ball makes him a prime target for home run props, especially in matchups against pitchers who struggle with control or give up a high number of fly balls. Alonso thrives in hitter-friendly parks, including Citi Field, where he regularly puts on power displays. 

Bettors can also find value in RBI props when Alonso faces weaker pitching staffs or in games projected to have high run totals. Keeping an eye on his splits against lefties versus righties can further fine-tune prop selections, as Alonso tends to do better against left-handed pitching.

Francisco Lindor

Francisco Lindor is one of the most versatile players on the Mets, contributing both offensively and defensively. In betting markets, Lindor is valuable in total bases and hits props, as he consistently puts the ball in play and has gap-to-gap power. His switch-hitting ability allows him to adapt to any pitching matchup, making him a reliable option regardless of who’s on the mound. Lindor’s speed is also an asset, so bettors can sometimes find value in stolen base props, particularly against teams with poor defensive catchers or slow pitchers. 

Additionally, in games where the Mets are expected to generate offense, Lindor’s ability to drive in runs from the middle of the lineup makes him an attractive option in RBI markets.

Max Scherzer

Though Max Scherzer is nearing the twilight of his career, his strikeout prowess remains one of the best in baseball. For bettors, his strikeout props are often worth targeting, especially in matchups against teams with high strikeout rates. Scherzer is known for his bulldog mentality on the mound, often pitching deep into games, which can make him a good option for betting on outs props or for taking Mets moneyline bets when he’s starting. 

However, bettors should be cautious with Scherzer as he’s dealt with injuries in recent seasons. Monitoring his health and velocity in the early innings can provide insights into how well he’s pitching on any given day, and live betting may provide opportunities if he’s on a roll.

Edwin Díaz

As one of the most dominant closers in the league, Edwin Díaz is almost automatic in save situations, which makes him a key player for live betting and prop markets. When the Mets are leading late in games, Díaz’s presence significantly boosts the team’s chances of locking down a win. His electric fastball and wipeout slider make him nearly unhittable, and he’s consistently able to rack up strikeouts in the 9th inning, which is valuable for bettors looking at K props in specific situations. 

His ability to close out games also makes him an important consideration for bettors who might want to play the under in tight games where Díaz is likely to get the ball in the final inning. If the Mets are leading heading into the 8th or 9th, live bets on the Mets’ moneyline become very attractive with Díaz lurking in the bullpen.

Francisco Álvarez

Francisco Álvarez is one of the most promising young players on the Mets, and his power at the plate is already evident, especially against left-handed pitching. Bettors should look for value in home run and hits props, particularly when Álvarez is facing pitchers who struggle to keep the ball in the park. As a developing talent, his consistency might not be fully there yet, but he has the potential for breakout games, which makes him a great option in longshot prop bets, especially for multi-hit games. 

His role as a catcher can also provide insights into his offensive production—days when he’s serving as the designated hitter or getting extra rest might make him an even more attractive target for player props, as fatigue won’t be as much of a factor.

New York Mets Schedule 

Don’t miss a single Mets game in the upcoming season:

New York Mets Odds

New York Mets Summary

The New York Mets are a fascinating team for bettors to follow, filled with high-profile players, rising stars, and unpredictable performances. As we’ve seen, injuries and aging players defined much of their 2024 season, but the future remains bright, especially with young talents like Brett Baty and Francisco Álvarez on the rise. Savvy bettors should keep an eye on the Mets’ pitching situation, player props for consistent sluggers like Pete Alonso, and the potential for bullpen dominance to influence game totals.

If you’re looking to elevate your betting experience, signing up for a handicapper service like the one at Scores and Stats.com could be your secret weapon. Their expert analysis and daily picks can help you navigate the volatility of betting on teams like the Mets, ensuring you’re making well-informed, profitable bets.